|
By Danny Kumin
1) I know about MTV, CATV, and CCTV. What's DTV?
DTV stands for Digital Television. The FCC has gifted broadcasters
with a few billion dollars worth of TV-band spectrum to commence
the changeover from the analog "NTSC" system we all know and love
to a powerful, flexible, and quite complex digital one. DTV's potential
benefits are: far greater video and audio quality; a more robust
signal---being digital, DTV is either there or it's not, there's
no such thing as snow, ghosting, and the like; and a highly configurable
transmission channel that eventually will empower a single station
to send out one channel of high-quality, or two or three (or more)
programs of lower image quality.
2) Okay... so then what's HDTV?
High-Definition Television. The short form is this: All U.S. HDTV
is DTV, but not all DTV is necessarily high-def. The new standard
encompasses 18 different video-image formats. Only three or four
of these are important, at least just now. The most frequently employed
high-def DTV flavor is 1080i, a format that delivers about triple
the perceived resolution of "regular" NTSC TV images (though such
comparative descriptions are notoriously subjective). Another currently
employed high-def option, 720p encodes a bit less internal resolution
but delivers twice as many fresh "fields" (frames, sort of) per
second; a lot of video experts consider 720p better for sports and
other motion-rich programming but prefer 1080i for typical TV and
film programming. The 480i DTV format is pretty much a digital equivalent
to today's analog (NTSC) TV---except that, digitally delivered,
it's immune from video noise (snow), ghosting, banding, and the
other visual flaws that weak-signal "POTV" suffers.
3) What else can DTV do?
Simultaneous data-casting and two-way interactive TV are two future
possibilities. And as already mentioned, a single DTV broadcast
channel might be used to transmit two, three, or even more 480i
(standard-definition) or even lower-def---programs. Put another
way, a single DTV channel can be applied to quantity instead of
quality. Just think: Montel, Jenny, and Maury, all from the same
"channel," all simultaneously. Is this a great country, or what?
4) How do I get my DTV?
Right now, just about every major U.S. market has at least one station
actively broadcasting DTV over the air, and several big ones---New
York, L.A., Washington D.C., Boston---have three or four or more.
All of these to date are on previously unoccupied slots of the UHF
band, and can be received via existing UHF antennas. (Eventually,
DTV stations will crop up here and there on the VHF 2-13 band, too.)
Signal-strength and freedom from multipath are both important---remember,
DTV is an on/off proposition---so antenna placement, cabling, and
in-line amplifiers can be key. Big-city or fringe-area dwellers
may be well advised to seek the help of an antenna pro.
5) What about cable TV?
Technically, there's nothing much impeding cable companies from
distributing DTV. As far as the actual wire is concerned, a DTV
channel is indistinguishable from a regular UHF station---electrons
is electrons. But the cable guys have been very slow to roll out
DTV, partially because the "head-end" equipment and other capital
start-up costs are steep, and partially because there are---so far---only
about 37 customers in each market who care. Cable is a huge cash-cow
industry, so why fix what ain't broke? What's more, unlike over-the-air
broadcasting there is no FCC requirement mandating a cable changeover.
Bottom line: Only a tiny handful of cable systems currently carry
any DTV stations. But this will change, with increasing speed. By
2005, certainly, DTV-on cable should be widespread.
6) Okay then, what about small-dish satellite?
DirectTV already has two channels broadcasting movies in 1080i hi-def;
Echostar's DISH network has one as well. In both cases, however,
you need some new equipment: for DirecTV systems, a specialized
antenna (that can "see" two satellites) and a combination DSS/DTV
receiver that doubles as an over-the-air DTV tuner; DISH systems
require a Model 5000 receiver with the addition of a hide-away Digital
Modulator component, which connects both to the Model 5000 receiver
and to the antenna input of an existing DTV tuner (or integrated
HDTV set), which is required.
7) So all I need is a UHF antenna and a new DSS or DISH setup and
I'm in business?
Uh, no---did I neglect to mention you also need a new TV? Actually,
as you may have surmised by now, first you need a DTV tuner or "set-top
box" (STB). This receives DTV signals from an antenna (or cable)
and sends them in a format that the TV can handle. STBs also provide
a digital-audio output, since DTV broadcasts carry sound in Dolby
Digital format, either stereo or 5.1-channel surround, with all
the same virtues found on DVDs. But as mentioned above, HDTV-capable
DirecTV receivers also function as over-the-air/cable DTV STBs,
making them the most economical solution by far if you also want
to make that upgrade.
8) You said something about a new TV?
Well, err---yeah. While nearly all DTV STBs can deliver standard-def
(480i) to today's TVs, this kind of defeats the purpose. (Though
this gets clearer, noise-free images---more or less DSS-like in
overall quality.) But to view the good stuff in high-definition
1080i and 720p formats, you need a far more capable television than
what you probably have right now. Whether a direct-view "tube" type
or a rear-projection model, this can be had in two basic forms.
"DTV-ready" sets have the image quality and wide bandwidth to display
DTV, but require an outboard DTV tuner---the set-top boxes already
mentioned. "Integrated DTVs" have all the requisite electronics
on board, with the STB built right in. Both types are available
in two screen formats. 4:3 DTVs have the screen shape familiar to
all from 50 years of television: just over-square, four units wide
by three high. 16:9 models display widescreen shapes that better
match the "anamorphic" aspect ratio of typical movies and produced-for-HDTV
programming.
9) So which is better, 4:3 or 16:9?
One school favors 4:3 screens even for DTVs, on the theory that
for years to come much programming, whether DTV or NTSC, will be
conventionally formatted. The 16:9 school maintains that, regardless,
displaying a widescreen movie (or other program) on a 4:3 set wastes
about a quarter of the set's potential resolution, since the wider
image necessarily leaves full-width black bars across the top and
bottom edges---and since those screen elements (pixels) are not
being used, the visible image can only be resolved by the remaining
three-quarters. (Of course, when you watch 4:3 material on a widescreen
set, the same is true in reverse.) For what it's worth, I myself
favor 16:9 sets: Once you've seen a high-def movie shown full-screen
in your own living room, it's awfully hard to go back.
10) Anything else?
A few items. Most DTVs/STBs also function as high-performance "regular"
(analog NTSC) TVs/tuners, too. Unfortunately, not all STBs are compatible
with all DTV-ready sets, due to non-compatible interconnect formats.
VGA, the familiar 15-pin cabling system used between PC and monitor,
is common, but "HD Component," a high-definition version of the
three-wire interconnect (usually RCA jacks) between top-line DVD
decks and high-end NTSC televisions, is quickly becoming the most
prevalent. Fortunately, many recent DTV sets include both inputs,
easing compatibility worries. (A minority of DTV-ready monitors,
mainly high-end front-projectors, accept only RGB/HV connection,
usually via four BNC jacks.)
Note: also that just as all DTV is not necessarily HDTV, not all
DTV-ready sets (or integrated DTVs) assure full-resolution display
of all hi-def formats. Most direct-view DTV sets present a 1080i
image intact, but only the highest-end rear-projection big-screens
can really make the same claim---but most that don't come very close,
and still look dramatically superior to regular TV. (A class of
less costly, "improved-definition" sets display DTV in 480p format,
a sort of halfway point between POTV and hi-def.) A solid majority
of DTV STBs and integrated sets perform line-doubling processing
on incoming "regular" NTSC TV signals, improving image quality somewhat
though the ultimate results vary widely from brand to brand and
model to model.
11) Geez, this all sounds expensive.
That's a statement, not a question. Oh, all right: Yes, DTV is big-ticket
stuff---for now. A DTV-ready set with reasonable hi-def compatibility
currently runs anywhere from around $1100 for the smallest direct-view
sets to $10,000-and-up for the top big-screen RP models. Set-top
boxes start at $650, and integrated DTV televisions at $3500 for
the most affordable, smaller-size direct-view models. These prices
will come down, of course, over time, but precisely how rapidly
is not entirely clear. On the one hand, DTV is not gathering momentum
as rapidly as did DVD, which dramatically out-performed most initial
expectations. On the other, with its hi-def allures and FTC mandate
DTV is, quite simply, the future---when it starts rolling in earnest,
it should quickly be become a juggernaut.
As always, the cost of being an early adopter is high. But so are
the advantages---especially if you like company. Because once friends
and family see hi-def movie and hi-def sports, their own OTV screens
are going to seem pale things. Make them bring the pizzas.
Danny Kumin is technical editor of Stereo Review's Sound
& Vision Magazine
|